Menu
Questions? Contact us at: 1-800-998-7750
FREE SHIPPING! On all orders over $75 LEARN MORE

Breathable Underwear Comparison Chart

Click on the header of each column to sort in ascending or descending order.

Breathable Underwear JHM Rating Cost/Each** Description
Depend Underwear for Women Good $1.07
  • Elastic only on lower half of leg openings
  • No leakage barrier
  • Cardboard-like consistency
  • Least absorbent
Depend Underwear for Men Good $1.25
  • Elastic only on lower half of leg openings
  • No leakage barrier
  • Cardboard-like consistency
  • Least absorbent
Depend Adjustable Underwear 16oz Good $1.25
  • Pull on but tabs may be adjusted for snug fit
Tranquility Daytime 25 oz Best $1.25
  • Double leg cuffs
  • Inner peach mat disperses fluid
Tranquility Overnight 34oz Best $1.25
  • Exactly like daytime product, except thicker and more absorbent
  • Available in XS
Attends Extra Better $0.97
  • No leakage barriers
  • One strip of elastic around entire leg opening
Attends Super Plus Better $0.97
  • Extra leakage barriers
  • More absorbent than Extra
Prevail Extra 31 oz. Better $0.99
  • Largest range of sizes: Youth to 2XL
  • Narrows through crotch for closer fit
  • Single leg gathers with large leg openings
Prevail Super Plus 50 oz. Better $1.11
  • Single leg gathers
  • Larger leg openings accommodate larger thighs
  • Channel collection system
Tena Plus 19oz Best $0.96
  • Fully elasticized legs with narrow elastic across crotch for narrower fit
  • Double leg guards
Tena Extra 21 oz Best $1.12
  • Same as Plus, but with disposal tape
Nightingale Underwear Good $0.69
  • Most economical


*absorbency listed when provided by manufacturer
**cost each based on Large size/case

All of the breathable underwear:
  • Are white in color
  • Have a cloth-like outer layer
  • Have tear away sides
  • Are easy to pull up and down
Most of the products are available in Small, Medium, Large and X-Large sizes.